After being seriously injured in a car accident in Massachusetts, discovering that the at-fault driver lacks sufficient insurance to cover your injuries can be devastating. You're facing mounting medical bills, lost wages, and a long recovery – yet the negligent driver's insurance policy falls substantially short of compensating you fairly. Fortunately, Massachusetts law may provide you with an additional avenue for recovery: underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage from a household member's auto insurance policy.
A skilled Massachusetts car accident lawyer plays a critical role in investigating all available insurance coverage after a crash. Determining which policies apply – and how they can be used to maximize your recovery – requires experience and a deep understanding of Massachusetts insurance law. An experienced attorney knows where to look for additional sources of compensation, such as underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage from a household member’s auto policy, which can provide crucial financial relief when the at-fault driver’s insurance is insufficient. By carefully reviewing every potential coverage option, your attorney can help ensure you receive the full and fair compensation you deserve.
Understanding Underinsured Motorist Coverage
Underinsured motorist coverage (UIM) is optional coverage that is designed to protect you when you're injured by a driver who has insurance, but not enough to fully compensate you for your damages. This optional coverage essentially fills the gap between what the at-fault driver's insurance pays and what you actually need to cover your losses, which is why our Framingham car accident attorneys highly recommend everyone obtain underinsured motorist coverage. If you have underinsured coverage, you should review your auto insurance policy to make sure you have sufficient coverage that will protect you just in case.
In Massachusetts, while liability insurance is mandatory, drivers are only required by law to carry minimum coverage of $20,000 per person and $40,000 per accident for bodily injury caused to others. Unfortunately, we have been seeing these minimum policies recently. These limits are often insufficient for serious injuries that result in extensive medical treatment, surgery, rehabilitation, or permanent disability especially nowadays considering the cost and expense of medical treatment.
If you are seriously injured in a car crash caused by a negligent or distracted driver who only carries the minimum coverage of $20,000 per person, having sufficient underinsured coverage can protect you from serious financial losses.
The Household Member Rule in Massachusetts
Massachusetts law allows injured parties to access underinsured motorist coverage from policies covering vehicles in the same household. This means if you live with a family member who has auto insurance with UIM coverage, you may be entitled to seek additional compensation under their policy – even if you weren't driving their vehicle at the time of the accident.
This household member provision recognizes that family members living together typically benefit from and contribute to household auto insurance policies. The law treats household members as having an insurable interest in one another, allowing them to access available UIM coverage when needed.
Who Qualifies as a Household Member?
Generally, in Massachusetts, a household member is someone who resides in the same home as the policyholder. This typically includes:
- Spouses
- Children living at home (including adult children)
- Parents
- Siblings
- Domestic partners
- Other relatives or individuals who share the same residence related by blood, marriage, or adoption
The key factor is that the person must be a resident of the same household at the time of the accident. Temporary absences, such as being away at college, typically don't disqualify someone from household member status if they maintain their primary residence at the home.
How to Access Household UIM Coverage
Accessing underinsured motorist coverage from a household member's policy involves several important steps:
1. Provide Proper Notice to the UIM Insurance Carrier
You must notify the auto insurance company providing the UIM coverage of your potential claim. Massachusetts law requires timely notice, so it's crucial to inform the insurer as soon as you recognize that the at-fault driver's coverage may be insufficient. Failure to timely notify the UIM insurance carrier of your potential claim may be fatal.
2. Exhaust the At-Fault Driver's Coverage & Obtain Permission to Settle
Before you can tap into UIM coverage, you must first pursue and exhaust the at-fault driver's liability coverage. This means settling or obtaining a judgment against the negligent driver for their full bodily injury policy limits. You cannot simultaneously pursue both the at-fault driver's insurance and UIM coverage. Additionally, if you receive an offer of settlement for the full bodily injury limits from the negligent or at-fault driver’s carrier, you must obtain permission to settle from your own auto insurance carrier (the UIM carrier) before settlement of the initial bodily injury claim with the negligent driver’s insurer.
3. Document Your Damages
Comprehensive documentation of your injuries and losses is essential. This includes:
- Medical records and bills
- Proof of lost wages and diminished earning capacity
- Documentation of pain and suffering
- Evidence of permanent impairment or disability
- Records of out-of-pocket expenses
4. Prove Your Claim
You'll need to demonstrate that your damages exceed the at-fault driver's insurance coverage and that you're entitled to additional compensation under the UIM policy. This often requires presenting medical evidence, expert testimony, and detailed financial documentation. In the event you are unable to reach a reasonable and fair settlement of your UIM claim, you have the right to force your claim to arbitration.
Important Considerations and Limitations
Policy Limits Apply
UIM coverage is subject to the policy limits of the household member's insurance. If your parent has a policy with $100,000 in UIM coverage, that's the maximum additional amount available, less the offset for the settlement or payment already received from the at-fault, negligent driver’s insurer. For example, if you were seriously injured in a car crash on Route 9 in Framingham, MA that was caused by a distracted driver and that driver only carries $20,000 in bodily injury limits, if your parent has $100,000 in UIM coverage and you received the full bodily injury limits of $20,000, you could only potentially recover an additional $80,000 from the UIM coverage ($100,000 in UIM coverage less the $20,000 you received from the other driver’s insurer).
The Critical Importance of Legal Guidance
Navigating underinsured motorist claims, particularly those involving household policies, can be complex. The procedural requirements for pursuing underinsured motorist coverage from a household member's policy are fraught with potential pitfalls that can jeopardize your entire claim. Massachusetts law imposes strict notice requirements, and failing to notify the UIM carrier within the required timeframe can result in a complete denial of coverage – even if you have a valid claim.
Furthermore, the prerequisites for accessing UIM coverage involve complex legal and strategic considerations that require experienced handling. You must exhaust the at-fault driver's policy limits before pursuing UIM coverage, but the manner in which you do so matters significantly. An experienced Massachusetts car accident lawyer understands how to handle settlements and releases to preserve your rights, properly document the insufficiency of the at-fault driver's coverage, accurately calculate the full value of your damages to demonstrate the need for additional compensation, and effectively counter insurance company defenses regarding household member status or policy interpretations. Without skilled legal representation, accident victims often discover too late that they've made irreversible mistakes that cost them thousands – or even hundreds of thousands – of dollars in rightful compensation.
Taking Action
If you've been injured by an underinsured driver in Massachusetts, don't assume the at-fault party's inadequate insurance is your only option. Explore whether household member UIM coverage might provide the additional compensation you deserve.
Time limits apply to these claims, so it's important to consult with a knowledgeable attorney promptly. By understanding your rights and the full scope of available coverage, you can work toward securing the compensation necessary for your recovery and financial stability.
Don’t forget, for answers to many questions and great information on how to get the best possible settlement in your accident case, get a copy of our book: 